Your source for the latest research news

Tuesday, 23 June 2020

When planting trees threatens the forest


Campaigns to plant huge numbers of trees could backfire, according to a new study that is the first to rigorously analyze the potential effects of subsidies in such schemes.



The analysis, published on June 22 in Nature Sustainability, reveals how efforts such as the global Trillion Trees campaign and a related initiative (H. R. 5859) under consideration by the U.S. Congress could lead to more biodiversity loss and little, if any, climate change upside. The researchers emphasize, however, that these efforts could have significant benefits if they include strong subsidy restrictions, such as prohibitions against replacing native forests with tree plantations.

“If policies to incentivize tree plantations are poorly designed or poorly enforced, there is a high risk of not only wasting public money but also releasing more carbon and losing biodiversity,” said study co-author Eric Lambin, the George and Setsuko Ishiyama Provostial Professor in Stanford’s School of Earth, Energy & Environmental Sciences. “That’s the exact opposite of what these policies are aiming for.”

There is no question that forests have an outsized role to play in efforts to slow global biodiversity loss and combat climate change by sequestering carbon as biomass. So it makes sense that tree-planting as a solution has gained traction in recent years with ambitious commitments, such as the Bonn Challenge, which seeks to restore an area of forest more than eight times the size of California by 2030, and Trillion Trees, which seeks to plant as many trees as its name implies.

A closer look reveals faults in the optimistic plans. For example, nearly 80 percent of commitments to the Bonn Challenge involve planting monoculture tree plantations or a limited mix of trees that produce products such as fruit and rubber rather than restoring natural forests. Plantations typically have significantly less potential for carbon sequestration, habitat creation and erosion control than natural forests. The potential benefit dwindles further if planted trees replace natural forests, grasslands or savannahs – ecosystems that have evolved to support unique, local biodiversity.



In the new study, the researchers critically examined another aspect of some mass-tree planting efforts: subsidies designed to encourage private landowners to plant trees. Such payments are widely proposed as a promising solution to a variety of environmental challenges. So, the scientists looked at one of the world’s longest-running and most influential afforestation subsidy policies, Chile’s Decree Law 701. The law, in effect from 1974 to 2012 and currently being considered for reintroduction, has served as the model for similar policies in a number of South American countries and international development projects.

“In light of global enthusiasm to plant a trillion trees, it’s important to reflect on the impact of past policies,” said lead author Robert Heilmayr, an assistant professor at UCSB, who worked on the study while a PhD student in the Emmett Interdisciplinary Program in Environment and Resources at Stanford’s School of Earth, Energy & Environmental Sciences. “Chile’s experience can help us understand the climate, ecological and economic impacts that might occur when governments pay landowners to establish massive tree plantations.”

Chile’s Decree Law 701 subsidized 75 percent of afforestation costs and provided support for ongoing plantation management. Lax enforcement and budgetary limitations hobbled prohibitions on the use of subsidies on already-forested lands, leading to situations in which the government subsidized the replacement of native forests with profitable tree plantations. Anecdotal evidence indicated the law’s subsidies further reduced native forest cover by encouraging the establishment of plantations on shrublands or marginal agricultural lands where forests might have naturally regenerated.

The researchers set out to quantify the full impact of the afforestation subsidies and calculate their effects on net carbon and biodiversity changes across the entire country. They compared the area of Chilean forests under three scenarios: actual observed subsidy patterns, no subsidies and subsidies combined with fully enforced restrictions on the conversion of native forests to plantations. They found that, relative to a scenario of no subsidies, afforestation payments expanded the area covered by trees, but decreased the area of native forests. Since Chile’s native forests are more carbon dense and biodiverse than plantations, the subsidies failed to increase carbon storage, and accelerated biodiversity losses.

“Nations should design and enforce their forest subsidy policies to avoid the undesirable ecological impacts that resulted from Chile’s program,” said study co-author Cristian Echeverría, a professor at the University of Concepción in Chile. “Future subsidies should seek to promote the recovery of the many carbon- and biodiversity-rich natural ecosystems that have been lost.”



More information: 

Impacts of Chilean forest subsidies on forest cover, carbon and biodiversity, Nature Sustainability (2020). DOI: 10.1038/s41893-020-0547-0

3 comments:

  1. Herpes is a sexually transmitted virus that primarily infects the mouth and the genitals. It is transmitted by bodily fluids – penetration isn’t required for transmission, oral-oral or oral-genital contact will suffice.I WAS ONCE HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS patient, I have HSV-I genitally and I'm one of the rare cases where I was infected by sexual contact. The person who infected me was unaware that he had it, and he tested negative on a blood test (he probably got it from his mother at birth and never had an outbreak in his life).I'm sure I have HSV-I (they did a culture of the fluid from the sores i had during my initial outbreak). So it is possible to contract HSV-I by asymptomatic asexual contact, so please people talk about this and prevent anyone else from getting it, I'm kind of going through something. Four years ago my love and I both had an OB and when I got the blood work done it came back negative. We were happy in the relationship so I learned to accept it and never really bothered to get tested again. Now, that we broke up I decided to get tested again. I came back negative for both HSV-1 and HSV-2 (got the news!) and have not had an OB since the initial one four years ago. My X on the other hand has had a few small outbreaks and never came back positive for HSV-1.Only the help of Dr Afrid where able to help me out with is Root and Herbs, if you are having any type of this disease or infection like HIV,CANCER OR ANY disease kindly email doctor Afrid for cure:( drafridherbalhome@gmail.com ) or Whatsapp him on +2349057260738.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello everyone, Words cannot describe how happy I am today after being cured from the herpes disease that I have been suffering from over 4 years now. I was infected with herpes and I have been living in shame and hiding it, but it became worse that I was searching for a cure from different means so desperate until I met with a lady online who was testifying about this herbal doctor called Dr Oniha. Who said she get her herpes disease cured with the use of Dr Oniha herbal medicine. I never believed but I have to give it a try because I was desperately in need of a cure to the deadly disease that i have been living with. So i contacted him and we discussed how to get the cure and Dr Oniha told me he cured with herbal medicine which i will order for and it will be delivered to me. Which I did what he wanted and to my greatest surprise the herbal medicine was delivered to me at my address which I gave to him, with instruction on how to apply it was also given to me by Dr Oniha. Then I started to use the herbal medicine, so after four weeks of using the herbal medicine, I saw physical changes and went for a test at two separate hospitals and I was totally cured, i am here to say thanks to you again Dr Oniha for saving me from the deadly herpes disease. Anyone with such disease can also contact Dr Oniha through his EMAIL: onihaherbalhome@gmail.com. You can also WHATSAPP him on +16692213962. website: www.onihaspelltemple.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello everyone, Words cannot describe how happy I am today after being cured from the herpes disease that I have been suffering from over 4 years now. I was infected with herpes and I have been living in shame and hiding it, but it became worse that I was searching for a cure from different means so desperate until I met with a lady online who was testifying about this herbal doctor called Dr Oniha. Who said she get her herpes disease cured with the use of Dr Oniha herbal medicine. I never believed but I have to give it a try because I was desperately in need of a cure to the deadly disease that i have been living with. So i contacted him and we discussed how to get the cure and Dr Oniha told me he cured with herbal medicine which i will order for and it will be delivered to me. Which I did what he wanted and to my greatest surprise the herbal medicine was delivered to me at my address which I gave to him, with instruction on how to apply it was also given to me by Dr Oniha. Then I started to use the herbal medicine, so after four weeks of using the herbal medicine, I saw physical changes and went for a test at two separate hospitals and I was totally cured, i am here to say thanks to you again Dr Oniha for saving me from the deadly herpes disease. Anyone with such disease can also contact Dr Oniha through his EMAIL: onihaherbalhome@gmail.com. You can also WHATSAPP him on +16692213962. website: www.onihaspelltemple.com

    ReplyDelete